🔥 Free Guide

Documenting Lost Personal Property

The hardest part. You lost irreplaceable things — not just furniture and electronics, but the treasures. This guide is practical: how to document what you lost, how to find evidence you didn't know you still had, and what it means for your insurance claim and your taxes.

First, a real acknowledgment: Nobody comes to this guide because they want to. You're doing this because you lost things that cannot be replaced — heirlooms, photographs, art, family treasures that have nothing to do with their dollar value. The documentation process is painful precisely because it requires confronting the loss item by item. Take it slowly. It's okay to do this in pieces over days or weeks.

Why Documentation Matters Beyond the Deduction

Post-TCJA, personal casualty loss deductions are suspended for most taxpayers in federally declared disasters — the Eaton Fire qualifies as one, so there may be a path to deduct personal property losses, but it's limited and your situation determines whether it applies. Your tax preparer will sort that out.

What documentation always matters for, regardless of the deduction question:

Insurance settlementYour documented inventory is the primary basis for negotiating your contents claim. Undocumented losses are frequently denied or underpaid.

Edison settlement allocationThe total documented contents loss helps establish the "property damage" component of the Edison settlement, which affects how taxable it is.

Basis for contents recoveryIf insurance paid you less than your documented loss, that matters for confirming the non-taxable character of any insurance proceeds.

Your own grieving processCreating an inventory, however painful, is a record of what your home contained. Many survivors say documenting helped them remember things they would have otherwise lost to grief.

Step 1: Mine Every Digital Source First

Before you try to remember anything from scratch, pull everything you can from digital sources. This is where most people find far more than they expected.

Surprisingly useful sources:

Google Photos / iCloud — search "living room," "kitchen," "bedroom," "garage." Photos you forgot you took will surface rooms, shelves, and item details.
Old real estate listing photos — if you bought the home or had it relisted, the listing likely has detailed room photos. Search Redfin, Zillow, or ask your real estate agent for old MLS photos.
Social media — Instagram, Facebook, even old holiday photos shared with family. Party photos, birthday celebrations, home improvement posts all show furnishings and possessions.
Amazon, Home Depot, Wayfair, Costco order history — years of purchase history with dollar amounts. Log in and export or print order history PDFs.
Credit card and bank statements — search for furniture stores, electronics retailers, jewelry stores, art galleries. Many purchases can be reconstructed from transaction records alone.
Email receipts — search your email for "receipt," "order confirmation," "invoice," "thank you for your purchase" going back as many years as you have email. Gmail and Outlook both support multi-year search.
Apple, Best Buy, Geek Squad records — device registration and repair records show serial numbers and purchase dates.
Insurance riders and scheduled items — if you had jewelry, art, or collectibles scheduled on your policy, those items have documented appraisals already.

Step 2: Room-by-Room Memory Walk

With your digital sources gathered, do a mental walk through each room. Be systematic — go from floor to ceiling, left to right. It helps some people to do this with a trusted person, or to have a family member walk through it with them verbally while someone else writes it down.

KitchenAppliances (stand mixer, espresso machine, etc.), cookware, dishes, glassware, knives, small appliances, pantry contents

Living RoomFurniture, TV/entertainment system, art, rugs, decorative items, books, lamps, plants

BedroomsFurniture, clothing, shoes, jewelry, watches, personal electronics, linens, art

OfficeComputer equipment, peripherals, office furniture, files, professional materials, instruments

GarageTools, sports equipment, bikes, vehicles not covered by auto insurance, seasonal equipment

Attic/StorageHoliday decorations, heirlooms, photographs, memorabilia, archived items, childhood objects

Special collectionsWine, art, coins, stamps, books, records, antiques, musical instruments, sports memorabilia

Sentimental itemsPhotographs (albums, loose prints), letters and correspondence, family documents, keepsakes from deceased relatives

The hardest category: Irreplaceable sentimental items — family photographs, letters, heirlooms — have no dollar value that captures their worth. Include them in your documentation anyway. The process of listing them creates a record of what your home held. For insurance purposes, these items may have some documented replacement value (archival printing services, for example). More importantly, listing them creates an honest record of the full scope of your loss.

Step 3: Format Your Inventory

A simple spreadsheet or table works well. Your insurer may have a specific form — check your policy or call your adjuster. If not, use this structure:

Item description	Room	Purchase year (est.)	Original cost ($)	Current replacement cost ($)	Evidence source
Samsung 65" QLED TV	Living Room	2021	$1,800	$1,400	Amazon order history
KitchenAid stand mixer	Kitchen	2017	$450	$500	Credit card statement
Grandmother's pearl necklace	Bedroom	Inherited 1995	Unknown	$2,200 (appraiser est.)	Memory / family photo
Leica M6 film camera	Office	2004	$1,200	$3,800 (used market)	Bank statement 2004
Mountain bikes (2)	Garage	2019	$3,200	$3,600	REI order confirmation
... continue for each item ...

Don't let perfect be the enemy of good. Estimated values are acceptable. "I don't remember the exact price but it was a MacBook Pro from 2020" is documentable — search Apple's historical pricing. The goal is a reasonable, good-faith reconstruction. Insurers expect estimates. Tax purposes require reasonable basis.

Step 4: High-Value Items Deserve Special Attention

Jewelry, art, collectibles, wine, musical instruments, and other high-value items are often underinsured and require special documentation for both insurance and potential Edison settlement allocation.

Jewelry & watchesPrior appraisals, purchase receipts, GIA certificates, photos, insurance rider documentation

ArtArtist, title, date acquired, purchase price or appraised value, photos, gallery receipts, provenance

Wine collectionsCellarTracker or Vivino logs, purchase receipts, storage facility records — these are often the most complete records available

Musical instrumentsBrand, model, serial number if remembered, purchase records, any professional appraisals

Collectibles / antiquesPrior appraisals, purchase records, photos, any online marketplace listings showing comparable sales

Photography equipmentCamera registration records, manufacturer serial numbers if remembered, insurance schedules

Step 5: What to Do With Your Documentation

For your insurer: Submit your contents inventory with your claim. The more documented it is, the stronger your negotiating position. If your insurer disputes items or values, a public adjuster can help negotiate.

For your tax preparer: Bring the full inventory spreadsheet plus totals. Your preparer will use the total documented loss to confirm whether insurance was below your basis (confirming the non-taxable character of insurance proceeds) and to support the Edison settlement allocation discussion.

For your Edison attorney: A documented contents loss supports the "property damage" component of your Edison settlement. Attorneys negotiating these settlements need to know the full scope of what was lost.

For yourself: Store your inventory in cloud storage — Google Drive, iCloud, Dropbox. Email it to yourself and to a trusted family member or attorney. Do not keep the only copy on a local device.

Book a Tax X-Ray →

Preparer Checklist → Basis Calculator → Start Here Guide →